What would u do if the guy....?

ok here is the go. i like this guy, he likes me. i have known him since like FOREVER. anyways he works away for months at a time and wen he comes bak i only get to see him once or twice. here is the twist, i like another guy to. and they both have the same name. they are both completly different and great in there own ways. i see the second guy more than the first guy and i find it easier to tlk to him but i know the first guy likes me more. we have tlked about livin together and everything, i just dont know. im so unsure can anybody help?